Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I keep hearing you need to write to think, but I just cannot. If an idea is not clear in my head I cannot write. I might be able to brain storm or do a mind map or dump words. But I cannot write.

I need to think through the idea in my head. I find I can create infinitely complex worlds in my head and go down various paths, words on a board/paper/tablet just help me direct that thought process. A lot of the time I do not even need that, I just need time to think through the idea in my head. Once I am clear then writing is a breeze.

Based on articles like this I have actually tried to write before the idea was clear in my head and lets just say I have never completed an article/document/anything any time I have done that.

Am I doing something wrong?



> If an idea is not clear in my head I cannot write.

Could you explain the idea verbally to another person? If so then you can just write down that conversation!

> lets just say I have never completed an article/document/anything any time I have done that.

I think that the point isn’t to produce writing for distribution to an audience, so you’re not supposed to be creating anything that’s “complete”.


I think that’s the point. The process of writing helps take an idea from vague to clear and concrete. The act of writing reveals weaknesses or gaps in your idea.

I often times think I ever a clear idea. But when I go to write it down its more like I have just the first two bullet points. The act of fleshing out this comment is a good example. :)


> If an idea is not clear in my head I cannot write.

Do you type on a computer or write with pen + paper?

I find that for me at least, "writing to think" has to be with pen/paper (a really good stylus + table combination can also work). It doesn't work when typing on a computer. When typing on a computer, I must have the thoughts ready as well.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: