Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

What's the penalty if you make an instrument tuned to A=442? Do you get dragged to the Hague International Criminal Court?



Several orchestras use different A's around 440, and nobody is getting prosecuted. 441 and 442 are popular right now, although some go as low as 438.

In baroque music, ~430 and 415 are also very common since they are thought to be the historical pitches of "A"


Friends recorded this album --https://alisonperkinsandnicolasbrown.bandcamp.com/album/all-... -- with A somewhere in the neighborhood of 360Hz.


360Hz?

That's so low, it's more like playing the piece a three semitones lower than an alternate choice for A4.

If the piece was in A, it would be more like playing it in F# (while still using A=440).

(Of course if you did that, the "sweet-spots of 12TET and its off-notes would be different, than if you played with A=360)


Some late baroque-period harpsichords had a selectable A: you could chose ~430, ~410, or ~390. The adjustment came from sliding the keyboards to the left or right based on which A you wanted. Supposedly A = 390 or even lower was used by the French in the renaissance, so you wanted your harpsichord to be able to accurately play historical music.


None that I'm aware of.

Tuning your orchestra high was sort of the 19th century equivalent of the modern loudness war. The problem is that orchestras tuning to ever higher pitches meant that singers had to sing higher to match, and it was putting serious strain on their voices, which can easily lead to injuries.

Having some sort of agreement setting a standard was just something of an "enough is enough" sort of moment. It just amuses me to no end that this was achieved by writing it into the Treaty of Versailles, of all things. We're settling a freaking world war, so let's make sure we settle the issue of orchestra pitch as part of the treaty.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: