Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

In my opinion decentralization is a non-feature. I.e., I don't believe in people waking up in the morning and thinking "gee, that app would be 10x better if decentralized". What people care about is (1) getting better connections with friends and colleagues. Here lunchclub is doing an amazing job. (2) getting better news then have a look at finclout.io. If you are a regular posted for whatever motivation, I don't think that the current state of social media works well. Decentralized Social as an implementation of a Decentralized Social Network is really terrible because it doesn't add anything to the user experience besides a pay-layer which in reality brings out the worst in people "Please buy my coin'


This is exactly right.

If the words "decentralized" are anywhere in your marketing of a decentralized social network, you have already lost ;p

I didn't intend to mean that by making a social network decentralized it would be 10x better. What I mean is, that by making a decentralized social network it opens up possibilities that are just not possible in a centralized network (or at least very hard).

And those possibilities are real tangible benefits to users/creators that don't directly have anything to do with 'decentralization'.


We are at the end of one cycle of "social" apps.

If we now stop and look back over the last 15 years we see

1. Art has degraded as Artists are optimizing their work for share-ability and a quick consuming audience.[1]

2. Social networks are pulling us further apart than bringing us together.[2]

3. Don't get me started on influencer culture[3]

[1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BPWkHtFPHH8&t=645s

[2] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-00805-0

[3] https://techcrunch.com/2022/01/10/hype-house-creator-economy...


What do you think will arise to address this? Whats the next cycle look like?


As I wrote in my original post, I like site like Lunchclub. Because it is a "single-player" experience where I don't need constantly be hyper-engaged, but can go in and say 'today I want to do x". Which feels more natural to me. Let's say I enter a lunchroom at work. There is Cathie from Accounting, Mark from Sales, and Marlene from IT. I can chose with whom I will eat lunch based on what I want to talk about that day. In opposite of yelling into the room / writing on the wall "Hey everyone, I want to talk about my a-ma-ze-ba-ll-s performance the other day" and then wait who replies / likes first to choose lunch.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: