Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm not sure if I see how boycotting a free version of a series based on a long dead author's public domain work makes a difference one way or another.


Yeah sanctions/boycott related to the Russo-Ukraine war is not even close to tangibly related to this.


Series director Shakhnazarov is one of the ultra pro-war and pro-Putin celebrities.

He’s almost daily on Russian TV spewing hatred against Ukrainians, Americans, minorities.

Be careful. It’s tempting to say “not all Germans”, but this case is clear-cut.

Anna Karenina is great and there’s plenty of other versions to watch.


These don't seem like good reasons to guard your brain from being exposed to him, they sound like good reasons not to be his friend.


Looking at how well propaganda works in Russia nowadays, I would be vary of being exposed to his recent films.


This interview clip of him pushing back against that narrative would seem to suggest your own case here is not so clear cut:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f4Ue45dJxy0


Thanks for trying to whitewash him, but no, we Russians know him very well.

Sterilization of anti-invasion people is one of the mildest things he suggests. He’s also a huge homophobe standing against “Western homosexual values”.

He’s been an almost weekly speaker on Russia 1 channel since 2000’s. His views were on clear display for years.

He’s one of the most hawkish anti-Ukrainian and ultraconservative Russian filmmakers save for Mikhalkov.

In exchange he’s been given tons of state awards and kept as a head of largest filmmaking company (Mosfilm). Also budgets for productions like this.

He had a couple okay-ish films during perestroika (Courier) but afterwards his sole job is a person shouting on state TV how he hates Western gays and Ukrainians.

So weird seeing his “works” on HN.


Thanks for trying to whitewash him

Please assume good faith; your arguments will carry more weight. I googled the guy, and that came up which clearly countered the invective against him here.


That is not exactly all that much. It is tiny little something ... and still promotes narrative of Ukraine being "bound" to Russia.


So the problem with him is that he's not sufficiently supportive? That's a scary goalpost move.


I will repeat comment you responded to: Series director Shakhnazarov is one of the ultra pro-war and pro-Putin celebrities. He’s almost daily on Russian TV spewing hatred against Ukrainians, Americans, minorities. Be careful. It’s tempting to say “not all Germans”, but this case is clear-cut.

Your link is not showing ANYTHING to cancel out the above or undo the damage. He is still spewing hatred. There is literally no goalposts movement, except yours.

Lets quote Shakhnazarov in state TV saying approvingly: "The opponents of the letter Z must understand that if they are counting on mercy, no, there will be no mercy for them. [...] There will be concentration camps, re-education, sterilisation of those who oppose the letter Z". This is him saying what should happen.


two different commenters...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: