Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

They should change the title. It is not a book for programmers about implementation of data science techniques. It is a book for managers about concerns surrounding the application of data science in various domains. The title should be something like "Social Concerns in the Application of Data Science."



It's a book for data scientists.

Data scientists are not software engineers.

They analyze data, they don't produce applications.

Not everything in the world is written for the benefit of software engineers.


I agree with you - mostly.

But in the book, computation is one of the three braids comprising data science. And they include software engineering in computation.

See book sections 1.2, 1.2.4, 2.1.3 etc

What I am trying to untie is, should data engineering be distinguished from data science, or not?


Previous poster didn't mention software engineers.


programmers != software engineers?


Yea I thought that was common knowledge.


If you're privy to the top-secret distinction between the two that nobody else knows, please share it.


same shit


While data science is not principally about programming, I think that having Norvig as one of the authors will lead to false expectations of the book unless the title is made more informative.


Social concerns are as a concern for engineers, as they are for their managers. However, I agree on changing the title somewhat, in order to indicate, that this is not a book about computer programming.


I think a more philosophical text by Norvig is quite welcome.

This is better than yet another machine learning algorithm book.


I didn't say there was anything wrong with the book, just the title.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: