Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

That's what I like about powershell. Every script can include a "SupportsShouldProcess" [1] attribute. What this means is that you can pass two new arguments to you script, which have standardized names across the whole platform:

- -WhatIf to see what would happen if you run the script;

- -Confirm, which asks for confirmation before any potentially destructive action.

Moreover these arguments get passed down to any command you write in your script that support them. So you can write something like:

    [CmdletBinding(SupportsShouldProcess)]
    param ([Parameter()] [string] $FolderToBeDeleted)
    
    # I'm using bash-like aliases but these are really powershell cmdlets!
    echo "Deleting files in $FolderToBeDeleted"
    $files = @(ls $FolderToBeDeleted -rec -file)
    echo "Found $($files.Length) files"
    rm $files
If I call this script with -WhatIf, it will only display the list of files to be deleted without doing anything. If I call it with -Confirm, it will ask for confirmation before each file, with an option to abort, debug the script, or process the rest without confirming again.

I can also declare that my script is "High" impact with the "ConfirmImpact = High" switch. This will make it so that the user gets asked for confirmation without explicitly passing -Confirm. A user can set their $ConfirmPreference to High, Medium, Low, or None, to make sure they get asked for confirmation for any script that declare an impact at least as high as their preference.

[1]: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/powershell/scripting/learn/...




I’m a bit confused (because I didnt read the docs)… does calling it with “—whatif” exercise the same code path as calling without, only the “do destructive stuff” automagically doesn’t do anything? Or is it a separate routine that you have to write?

Cause if it is an entirely separate code path, doesn’t that introduce a case where what you say you’ll isn’t exactly what actually happens?


Well, just read the...

> because I didnt read the docs

Ouch.

> Or is it a separate routine that you have to write?

If you are writing a function or a module what would do something (eg API wrapper) then of course you need to write it yourself.

But if you are writing just a script for your mundade one-time/everyday tasks and call cmdlets what supports ShouldProcess then it works automagically. Issuing '-whatif' for the script would pass `-whatif` to any cmdlet what has 'ShouldProcess' in it's definition. Of course if someone made a cmdlet with a declared ShouldProcess but didn't write the logic to process it - you are out of luck.

But if have a spare couple of minutes check the docs in the link, it was originally a blog post by kevmarq, not a boring autodoc.


It's the first option. And yes, sometimes you have to be careful if you want to implement SupportsShouldProcess correctly, it's not something you can add willy-nilly. For example, if you create a folder, you can't `cd` there in -WhatIf mode.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: