> Oh, that tiny little detail where it has become impossible for almost anyone to actually send email from home, either because residential IPs are all marked as spam, or because your provider is giving you an incomplete internet connection that blocks outgoing SMTP.
Well, by "provider" I was referring to the hosting provider. I wouldn't typically recommend hosting from home [0]. Apart from the issues you identified, over the course of 20 years I've moved house multiple times so would have had email downtime and likely had to change IP address, likely leading to reputation starting again from zero (at best) or picking up an IP with bad history (much worse).
> Can someone tell me why providers ever thought it was a good idea to block entire IP ranges?
If you repeatedly receive spam from multiple IPs within a given ASN, and the abuse contact is non-functional or doesn't actually resolve the problem, it is fairly reasonable to consider that the ASN is friendly to spammers. Blocking by prefix rather than entire ASN is a bit less of a sledgehammer, but follows the same logic.
[0] If you own your house, have no plans to move any time soon, and can get a connection from a provider who is willing to give you a stable static IP that isn't categorised as 'residential/dynamic' by the major lists, hosting from home should be fine. But that's quite a few 'if's.
Well, by "provider" I was referring to the hosting provider. I wouldn't typically recommend hosting from home [0]. Apart from the issues you identified, over the course of 20 years I've moved house multiple times so would have had email downtime and likely had to change IP address, likely leading to reputation starting again from zero (at best) or picking up an IP with bad history (much worse).
> Can someone tell me why providers ever thought it was a good idea to block entire IP ranges?
If you repeatedly receive spam from multiple IPs within a given ASN, and the abuse contact is non-functional or doesn't actually resolve the problem, it is fairly reasonable to consider that the ASN is friendly to spammers. Blocking by prefix rather than entire ASN is a bit less of a sledgehammer, but follows the same logic.
[0] If you own your house, have no plans to move any time soon, and can get a connection from a provider who is willing to give you a stable static IP that isn't categorised as 'residential/dynamic' by the major lists, hosting from home should be fine. But that's quite a few 'if's.