Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Aren't all function pointers dynamic invocation?

Given that compilers can be smart-enough to detect "non-dynamic" function-pointer invocation (e.g. when an execution-trace proves that a function-pointer parameter always points to the same function address), it's not safe to say that "all" function pointer invocations are dynamic.

Another case to consider is when one implements (Smalltalk-style) OOP with message-passing: in many cases it's possible to build that without needing to use function-pointers at all.




Also you have a type system. And even in C function pointers have types.

So you can exclude many things that would in-principle be possible.


> C function pointers have types.

I'm not 100% sure, but i remember that i could have have both a two and three function argument be called with the same function pointer, its probably UB however i think that as long as any dereferenced functions adhered to the standard argument behavior of the platform specific calling convention it worked, and i dont think gcc, clang or msvc complained, but my memory might be wrong.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: