Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

^ This! At least here in New Zealand almost all perks of "extended" warranties are useless, as pretty much all things you buy here are already covered under our consumers guarantee act.



Nothing is free. An extended warranty is an insurance policy, the purchase price for it is the premium. It's pretty much the same for the original warranty. It may be included in the purchase, but it's still just an insurance policy that the manufacturer has rolled into the price of the product.

So when you have strong regulation like a consumer guarantee act, it just means everything you buy is priced higher to account for it.


"An extended warranty is an insurance policy"

Not at all, insurance company protects you from unpredictable events it has no control over - robberies, hurricanes, etc.

The manufacturer has complete control over how long the products will last.

You know what we call selling protection from something you control? A racket.

"Nice Jewlery Store you have there, would be a shame if something happened to it"


Very true, which is why it's such a scam to sell extended warranties here in NZ, as you get almost no value for it. Yet allot of the big retail chains still do it.


I think the real scam is the tax forcing everyone to pay for the warranty whether they want it or not.


It's a reasonable of life warranty in nz. 2 years is standard for products. But a fridge would reasonably expect to last for all least 4 years so the manufacturer would be obligated to cover it if say the compressor failed. But if it was something like an electric toothbrush then 2 years would be the warranty.


This is ... not true, though?

Consumer goods are more expensive in most of Europe, sure, but that's because of VAT - after adjusting for VAT, the price is usually the same.

This makes sense if you consider that customer protection usually covers (1) returns and (2) defective goods. Returns are not exactly a cost to the retailer - they can still sell the merchandise, and replacing defective goods obviously only applies if you stock them. If you weren't selling bad goods, you wouldn't have that problem.


Nothing of value is free.

But many things of no value are costly.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: