Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> you are build for their OS, using their APIs and SDKs, targeting their customers.

Which takes us right back to "Imagine if in the past Apple would have had to pay 30% of their gross to Microsoft in order to be allowed to run their software on Windows."

I'm apple's customer, and I'm these apps' customer. None of them own me. Apple's not doing any meaningful referring, it should be possible to opt out of any referring they do, and building for an OS should not cost these fees.




You choose to do business with Apple, knowing the terms of the deal. At a certain point that’s determinative. Apple doesn’t have a majority user base in the US. Google is ready and waiting for defectors.


This is excellent news. You see, I work in networks. I (helped) write the driver that is used on the carrier side of 4G networks, and it's open source, so, like Apple, I retain the copyright. A driver that you have undoubtedly used to order pizza. My code is the "platform" you used to pay that pizza! I am entitled to compensation, and apparently 30% ... wow. Great news!

I'll have 30% of everything you ever paid over your phone now.

Remember, you CHOSE to pay using "my" infrastructure, so it's only fair that I be compensated for that.

Or is your point that these rules only apply to massive US corporations?


You say this as if there aren't deals between patent holders and platforms that are based on revenue percentages.


Patents are quite different from infrastructure. And critical patents are normally kept from charging very high rates by multiple mechanisms.


There are infrastructure agreements which function on revenue basis too.

Critical patents have some limitations, but only because of agreements which were reached in the establishment of specific standards.

If you own the IP, you get to decide how you're compensated for it.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: