Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> A good prank is when the two parties can laugh about it together when it’s done.

Hm, that's now how I have the definition of a prank in my dictionary. To me it is a practical joke which usually has two required components, a prankster and the person the prank is being played on. Audience optional. To assume that they both have the same sense of humor seems to be a recipe for disappointment.

This is everyday life at tradeshows. Seriously. I've had people trying to destroy 100's of thousands of $ for kicks to see if the gear was as solid as we claimed it was. (it was).

As tradeshow pranks come this really does not register.

> at the expense of someone else

That's a prerequisite for a prank, it is quite literally played on someone else by definition, without that it isn't really a prank.

Whether you can see the humor of it or not depends on your personal make-up. People ring the doorbell here occasionally. I have a pretty badly injured right leg. So I go down a couple of flights of stairs to open the door.

Every now and then this includes neighborhood kids who will be in hiding at the end of the driveway. Usually their giggling gives the game away. Needless to say, their sense of humor is different than mine on this subject. That does not mean that I don't think it isn't a successful prank from their perspective, in fact the fact that they know this probably adds to the spice.

But then I think 'they're just kids' and leave it at that.

All the 'holier than thou' and concern trolling in this thread is completely over the top, in real life people pull pranks, some laugh, some don't. But it's not enough to go judge people to the degree that is done here.




I'd like to point out that just because you are tolerant of others pranking you does not mean that someone else (who might potential be fearing for losing his job) may find it funny.

In fact there's a common saying "It's just a prank bro" (1) which is used when people do questionable things as "pranks", almost always causing the other person to get worried. And (un)fun fact, courts have not taken kindly to these "pranks" (2, 3).

Side note, if you are interested you could put up a note with a message saying that you have an injured leg and take longer to come to the door. It might help delivery folks, and may also reduce/stop children from ringing the bell.

1. knowyourmeme.com/memes/its-just-a-prank 2. https://www.legaldefense.com/blog/2021/april/when-is-it-not-... 3. https://www.boydbuckingham.com/2018/04/whats-funnier-than-a-...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: