Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Sure, but in the Strongtowns models there is not space for cars - at least everyone owning a car they only use for weekends.

Only the rich own cars. Or those that live outside the urban core.

Welcome to our future if Strongtowns has a say.




There is plenty of space for cars if you stack them. That's a rather successful model in Japanese cities. Free surface parking has an outsized negative impact on cities.

BTW, it's already kind of true that only the rich own cars, car ownership correlates very strongly with household income.


>BTW, it's already kind of true that only the rich own cars, car ownership correlates very strongly with household income.

Of course it correlates. Rich households can afford more cars per person and can indulge in specialized vehicles (e.g commuter car).

Rich families have a sedan for each commuting parent and maybe another less specialized car (e.g. minivan or 3-row SUV) that only sees weekend use. Poor families pile into a Saturn.

That the ability of the poor family to own and operate that Saturn confers a far greater standard of living jump than cars 2-N do for the rich family. It also has a much greater impact on the health of the broader economy.

To intentionally place monetary constraints on vehicle ownership would be unwise because you have to price out all the poor before you start making meaningful dents in the (relatively) wealthy professionals who commute across the inner suburbs and into urban environments.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: