Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The vast majority is plant matter. It wastes a lot of energy to chase prey. Plants don't move much. Last I read it was on the order of 80% plants, with a lot of insects being most of the meat.



You may be right that the majority is plant matter, but in salmon season bears gather at salmon runs and waste little energy in snatching fish as they leap up the cascades. See [1]. (Although individual bears do compete for the best fishing spots, they are in a "fish in a barrel" situation when they get one. They don't have to chase anything, just grab and chew.)

[1] https://explore.org/livecams/brown-bears/brown-bear-salmon-c...

Edit to add:

Here's an article [2] from 2018, How many salmon will a bear eat?

Excerpt: Adult male bears on Kodiak ate the most salmon on average, consuming an incredible 6,146 pounds (2,788 kg) per bear per year! Adult females ate 3,007 pounds (1,364 kg). Salmon consumption varied among subadult bears, independent juvenile bears between 2.5 and 5.5 years old. Subadult females ate 1,248 pounds (566 kg) while subadult males ate 1,305 pounds (592 kg) of salmon per bear per year.

[2] https://medium.com/@exploreorg/how-many-salmon-will-a-bear-e...


The bears catch so many salmon on some rivers that they eat only the most nutritious parts and leave the rest of the carcass for scavengers.


Correct. See my post and [1]. I saw this behavior myself.

It's not just standing and snatching fish out of the stream, though. Most bears have to chase the fish and try to catch them, often failing.

[1] https://photos.app.goo.gl/mXMHAjDyQNDjFqjw8


costs a lot to feed bears. this years salmon price is estimated at $14-20\lb. if we take the average, a bear eats more then $100k a year worth of salmon.


It's cheaper when you buy it near the source.


True, and probably cheaper buying in that kind of bulk. Still an impressive amount of fish.


Also, breaking down plant matter is very energy intensive. Salmon is very close to what animals need, sort of by definition.


While that is true for inland brown/grizzly bears, the coastal brown bears under discussion in this article eat huge quantities of spawning salmon during the summer and early fall.

They get much larger and much fatter than the inland bears as a result.


More than 20% for many inland grizzly bears, e.g. Yellowstone:

  Approximately 45 ± 22% (equation image ± SD) of the assimilated nitrogen consumed by male grizzly bears, 38 ± 20% by female grizzly bears, and 23 ± 7% by male and female black bears came from animal matter.
https://wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/jwm...

Diet varies a lot by region. Figure 7 here: <https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Bruce-Mclellan/publicat...>

Shows that for female grizzlies without salmon in their diets, % meat seems to vary from around 0% to 60% based on population.


Assimilated nitrogen != calories. Fish are rich in protein; plants have a large share of digestible carbohydrates.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: