Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That does not at all explain their overly aggressive approach and (initial) lack of attribution.


It explains their course of action, as Jorge was not flexible in his "my way or highway" approach. And I would also either ditch or fork earlier version, if maintainer of API is sabotaging my project.

IMO, making fork, instead of integrating or writing their own(without the need to acknowledge original author due to significant changes to a code) shows struggle of dealing with this situation. I think that it is too harsh to declare it as intent that is directed specifically towards Jorge, but they took that route where they were vulnerable to attack. In the place of users of Jorges API(because I'm not related in any way to anyone here - I'm just reading this piece an making my comment), if I knew that Jorge would be taking this to public and rally a mob to torch other side, I would be making my own code, but then I don't exactl'y understand using so many unowned modules on personal project, as it is vulnerable to do so in first place(it saves some time initially, but if they are improving code so much, that it is running faster, then that is not an issue to write their own) - and one of the vulnerabilities is exactly this situation.

I am sympathising here with Jorge, but only on that side where his efforts in making that API might be significant to him. I don't see anything else good from this situation, as he is not going to get back his main user and others might avoid using his other works because of this conflict. Well, he might have a temporary victory in getting his name in fork, but that will just lead to ditching any code of his in future. The important part is distinguishing author side and his ability to communicate with users and once again I can sympathise with him as author, but not as user, as his communication and solving issues are taken from defensive-aggressive side. You can like or dislike my opinion, but that does not change that fact.


> It explains their course of action, as Jorge was not flexible in his "my way or highway" approach.

I don't understand where this conclusion is coming from as it doesn't seem Andrey raised any concerns with colorette prior to his aggressive actions.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: