Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Or you can use cross-platform solutions which are themselves good tools, and disregard platform-specific semantics in favor of globally good UI/UX and let your tool stand on its own with no need for unnecessary, repetitive, error-prone platform porting.



> Or you can use cross-platform solutions which are themselves good tools

No such thing exists.

> and disregard platform-specific semantics

Again, this is a bad thing for users.


> > and disregard platform-specific semantics

> Again, this is a bad thing for users.

Can you make a supporting argument for this? You state it as fact. I do not see why globally strong UI/UX should be a bad thing for users just because it disregards some standards of unknown quality on an unknown platform. Most methods of interacting with applications today are standardized and have no platform reliance; it is unclear to me why a developer whose tool delivers value in and of itself would suddenly not be delivering value to users just because their UI implementation did not perfectly match said user's preferred OS' UI standards. Actually, it's perfectly clear to me that the opposite is true.


> I do not see why globally strong UI/UX should be a bad thing for users

Except "globally strong UI/UX" is usually just design wankery that totally ignores decades of usability studies.

> just because it disregards some standards of unknown quality on an unknown platform.

Yeah, because the bleeding Windows UI guidelines that were in force for decades and known by hundreds of millions -- or are we in billions territory? Probably -- of users are "some standards of unknown quality on an unknown platform" nowadays.

Pull the other one, it's got bells on it.


Maybe you have not actually used a good platform with good standards?


Maybe you shouldn't revert to facile claims which don't even support your point, such as implying that a single good platform with good standards justifies never building anything cross-platform ever in any context?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: