Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> In highly competitive physical sports there be would no woman at all in the olympics for example.

In (edit: some) highly competitive physical sports there would be no person below median height at all in the olympics for example.

We can slice and dice all sorts of extremely visible inborn characteristics that will over time hopefully have just as much cultural relevance as sex or gender, as the cultural relevance of sex and gender decreases [0]. As that happens, we’re going to have to reevaluate what we culturally look for in sports. At the amateur level, hopefully this isn’t too hard, but I have no idea whether it will make professional sports more or less accessible.

[0] While height is mostly out of your control, it’s still unclear which of the kids in tryout team will end up tall enough to compete. That’s where sex and gender are more of a clear split, because you know most of the kids on the girls team won’t end up on a men’s team, so the split remains stable as they grow up.



I consider gymnastics as a highly competitive physical sport and the best gymnasts are usually below median height.


Doh, I meant in some of them, not all of them. I had basketball in mind, but words are hard.


"In highly competitive physical sports there would be no person below median height at all in the olympics for example."

That's not true for all sports. Gymnastics is highly physical and favors short people. Likewise, wrestling and Judo favor people who are short for their weight.

I do think height classes would make sense in basketball though, just as we have weight classes in combat sports.


Yeah that’s on me. Writing is hard. I meant some, not all.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: