Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Given that China has pretty much been a repressive dystopia forever

You mean communist China, or the China that existed prior to that? The time when the British had influence (control?), or prior to that? How long does this "forever" go back, and what makes you think they prior periods where repressive dystopias?

> it's not weird to assume that that's their end state

We're talking about a country that went through a violent rebellion just over seventy years ago, changing the method of government and economic system entirely in the process. And in the last few decades, they've made sweeping changes to the economic model again to the point where in some places it's extremely capitalistic where it was entirely communism based.

> (though I'm confused about what "end" you're referring to).

I guess it's decided the same way you decide who "beat" the other in not being a repressive dystopia. You can't have a winner without an end, so however people thought that meant. I don't see why my response should have any other rules than the premise it's responding to.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: