Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

>"For some people it's indeed a better choice..."

And that's the choices they make ( assuming they are in position to make it at all). I am not going to judge either.

>"she got out quite well..."

You do not know what she would do given a choice. Also she's been sentenced to 35 years. The only reason she's out is that Obama had commuted her sentence. Otherwise the life for her will be over.




So in other words, "the system" worked for Manning to some degree, right?

She wouldn't have gotten the pardon if she didn't have some legitimate claim to being a whistleblower.

Of course, a sentence of 35 years sounded ridiculous in her case, but there are legitimate ways to change those laws or ameliorate the consequences. And there is also an argument why disclosure of secrets should carry hefty prison terms, as it can result in casualties. Probably even did, in her case.

I'm not saying she is a terrible person or even that she deserved to be in prison for seven years. I'm just stating that her actions were clearly illegal and had a lot of unambigiously negative consequences. Same thing for Snowden, though he lost a lot of my sympathy by defecting to an enemy state...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: