Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

All that assumes you have some stuff to set up that global map, and that means that setup code is a requirement.

I end up writing lots of library code. Sometimes that library code is called from within a command line utility I created, sometimes it's called from a web service, sometimes it's just a small driver script because I'm not developing or testing the utility, but the library code itself.

I can make that include to set up the shared global and try to make sure it's included in all instances and all ways I want to use the code, or make all the call sites resilient to it not existing, or I can just use the included OS mechanism for doing this and since that's always available, I get it for free.

Also, dry run mode isn't necessarily something you want set in a config. It's generally something you run once or twice prior to running for real (the normal case) or while in development/debugging. It's not something you would want to set in code and accidentally forget and push live, and generally a good dry run mode will look like it succeeded without actually succeeding, mocking responses that would fail along the way, because you aren't testing one small thing you're testing a workflow of some sort generally which has a few steps.

That said, I fully admit the trade-off might go a different way for different languages. Using a compiled strongly typed language may mean there's enough bits to check that you need to write a debug/dry run helper function to make it convenient, so there's not a lot lost by requiring setup in that as well. But for something like Perl (and I assume Python and Ruby and JS, to almost the same degree) where I can do:

    warn "Calling out to foo() with args: " . Dumper($args) if $ENV{DEBUG} and $ENV{DEBUG} >= 2;
    foo($args) if not $ENV{DRY_RUN};
and it will be completely valid, obvious and idiomatic with zero additional work, there's a real draw to using environment vars for these two specific cases (even if not for all config).



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: