Sometimes my comments get modded down, which is cool. However sometimes I wish I know why they did.
Should down modding be a comment function. E.g. should users with enough karma to down mod comments explain why they did?
Mostly I just want to write better comments. Sometimes it's frustrating to see a comment drop to 0 thinking it was a valid point and not knowing why someone with great karma didn't agree.
- Trolling (examples: "you're clearly a mac fanboy", "you want fries with that?")
- Be trite or redundant (examples: "lol", "i agree", "+1 interesting", "upmod parent")
- Personal attacks (examples: "I bet if you were him you'd say 'go away customer, I only write my software in Rails/LISP/Haskell'")
- Poor attitude (examples: "shut the f*ck up", "that's dumb")
- Being incoherent, in jest or in seriousness (examples: "mahler called, he wants his symphony back")
- Rambling on without saying anything (examples: "then i went to see my dentist, but that's a whole another story...")
- And, last but not least, disagreement. Theoretically, you will not be downmodded for saying something disagreeable. In practice, however, downmodding on disagreement does happen. Some misuse is to be expected, and all we can do is live with that.