Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Canada has socialized healthcare.

200 to 300 thousand travel to the US for healthcare every year. That's with population of ~30 million. Extremely common.

Which begs the question, why do they travel to the terrible USA, when wonderful social care in Canada is so amazing on paper, with wait lists measured in years?




Getting an accurate portrait of Canada as a whole is very difficult, as healthcare is a provincial responsibility.

As a Canadian however, it would not surprise me if most of the people traveling were upper class people trying to bypass the waiting lists.

You have to understand that this is inevitable as long as our systems don't have the same level of fairness and people are allowed to "choose" their system. Of course privileged people will choose the system that they can benefit from most, whereas unprivileged people cannot afford to choose.

This is not to say that our Canadian healthcare systems are perfect (far from it), but rather that some of them attempt to promote fairness (in service quality and rapidity), thereby negating the greater privilege of wealth relative to less fair systems such as yours.

This practice of healthcare tourism does of course take some pressure off the system for unprivileged people, so it's hard to say it's all bad on the whole. But don't expect the situation to change regardless, as we are also ruled by the wealthy, and they do so like to have freedom of choice.

By the way, the position on the waiting list is often adjusted according to the urgency of one's situation, so people who travel to reduce waiting time would not have been in critical condition on average, not to mention they may simply be traveling to get services that are legislated differently in Canada (as I believe cosmetic surgery can be, depending on the province).


>>By the way, the position on the waiting list is often adjusted according to the urgency of one's situation

This is only technically true, and ignores the fact that many medical procedures that are done when something is not critical means making a full and complete recovery with no life long effects but delaying the treatment while sitting on a wait list until the issue becomes "critical" means the problem may only be able to be partially rectified and the person may suffer from life long effects due to the delay in treatment

At the end of the day government run health systems control costs by limiting the supply and ignoring the demand. This creates an untenable system that can never be "fair" to anyone.


You have to remember that to some, as long as everyone is in abject misery, it's "fair".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: