Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This logic seems to be flawed on the face of it.

People do in fact have life-changing experiences through social contact. I.e. by having conversations and meeting people of kinds they hadn’t previously experienced.

It’s therefore reasonable to expect, just by the numbers, that a novel social platform with millions of users interacting can create or facilitate such experiences for some people.




> This logic seems to be flawed on the face of it.

It is really not. If your reaction to finding out about clubhouse, is to breakdown crying, about the new voice chat app that you have found, then you almost certainly have mental issues that you should try to resolve.

> by having conversations and meeting people

Thats great. But if your reaction to this, is to talk about this like it is a new religion that you have joined, then you almost certainly have legitimate issues in your life, that you should seek professional help for.

Its a voice chat app. That is fine to like it. But having a coming to jesus moment, means that you are almost certainly mentally ill, and need help.

> just by the numbers

Yes, I am sure that just by the numbers, that there have been multiple people who will talk about the new voice chat app, like it is the greatest thing to ever come into their life, and they will break down crying while talking about it, as if it their new cult/religion that they have joined.

But that is the problem. Those people need professional help.


I’m not sure where you are getting the impression that people are having religious experiences on clubhouse. Care to share your sources for that?

As for crying as a result of positive social contact, why do you think that is abnormal?

People cry on FaceTime or Zoom calls, or the phone as a normal part of social interaction what makes you think they wouldn’t cry sometimes through interactions on clubhouse?

Are you a mental health profession?

I’d be curious to know what diagnostic criteria or research models you are using to determine that people should seek help.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: