Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's a "tax" on un-invested capital, sure, in the same way a fine is a "tax" on undesirable behavior.

I think tax is the wrong word because a tax implies a kind of tithe on top of desirable behavior. A fine implies that you are being penalized for undesirable behavior. I think the latter is a more apt description.

Your mattress full of hundos is detrimental to the economy and you are being fined for maintaining it.

Savings accounts are not an example of unproductive capital because they collateralize loans. That's why they're not subject to the inflationary haircut. They're not particularly productive hence the low return, which may be below inflation. However, that's an ROI below benchmark, not inflation. i.e. savings accounts are just a bad investment. Bad investments will exist in any market conditions.

Personally I maintain a small cash buffer in a savings account and I pay the (small) delta between inflation and interest rate as a fee for liquidity.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: