Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm not sure anyone in this thread knows what inflation is. If the cost of housing rises, that is inflationary against all other fungible assets that could be used to purchase housing. That is, one requires a larger quantity of all assets -- dollars, crypto, stocks, bodily fluids, etc. -- to acquire a roof over one's head. Only if the cost to purchase housing is somehow lower by holding value in a particular asset could you get ahead of the inflationary pressure caused by rising housing prices. Too many cryptonuts think inflation just means "money supply." That is play time economics.


Inflation as it's being used in this conversation and in general is measured against a specific currency. I mean you could, I suppose, use the term to measure the cost of a specific asset against a basket of other assets, but that is not really standard and if you wish to use it that way you should qualify your usage as such to avoid confusion.

Using your approach you'd end up saying something like Apple is experiencing inflation because its price has gone up more against housing, oil, General Electric stock. Yeah, that could be done, but it's not the way the word is being used in this conversation. We're talking about inflation of US dollars against a basket of goods as measured by the CPI as opposed to talking about an increase in housing costs relative to Apple stock.


The only thing you said that is true is in the last sentence. The basket of goods affecting inflation is heavily influenced by the cost of housing. All you care about when holding a store of value is how much of that denominated fungible asset can be exchanged for things you need to live.


Ah, so according to you my first sentence is false then? Let's see what a simple Google search yields:

>Inflation is the decrease in the purchasing power of a currency.

>Inflation is the decline of purchasing power of a given currency over time.

>Inflation is a persistent rise in the average level of prices over time in a given currency.

> Inflation occurs when prices rise, decreasing the purchasing power of your dollars.

Those are literally the top search results for "inflation" when I Google the term. Now certainly your Google search for that term may differ from mine and you are certainly welcome to share your findings. Until then I will rest satisfied that my first sentence expressing that inflation is almost always understood to be with respect to a currency is also true.


I think you're definitely learning more just reading Google. Enjoy!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: