Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> The point is that this "decentralized" movement has a central organization that has a lot of money donated to it,

It doesn't, though. There are several large national organizations (BLMGNF, M4BL, and others) associated with the movement, not a single central organization.

> and that the central/important tenets of that central organization probably has some measurable influence in deciding which "decentralized" parts of the organization get funding/donations/focus/marketing.

The tenets of the various organizations do obviously play a role in how they distribute funds, and the tenets of the various large and small organizations play a big role in which of them get funding donated to them by various donors.

> So if the "BLM" organization views the nuclear family as something that has to be abolished

Which, contrary to the misrepresentations, none of the major movement-related organizations do; a number of movement-related organizations have said things about policies which are punitive to families outside of that assumed norm as part of institutional racism especially in the presence of other institutional and social factors which result in more Black children not being raised in nuclear families.

> then one can assume that they wouldn't donate to local BLM chapters that don't subscribe to that idea

One can also assume that, if that were true, it would be competitive fundraising advantage to other movement organizations (e.g., direct donations to local orgs, if this really was the single central organization) without that belief, to the extent that the belief conflicted with the grassroots. But since there is neither a single central org nor any major org with the viewpoint being criticized, it's moot.

> With this whole "decentralized" argument, we might as well say the Republican/Democratic parties are decentralized

No, you might as well say the that the “right-to-far-right political alignment” and the “center-right to moderate left political alignment” are decentralized movements.

The Democratic and Republican parties are centralized organizations, in ways that the BLM movement is not.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: