Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Report on an Unidentified Space Station (1982) (uchicago.edu)
133 points by optimalsolver on March 9, 2021 | hide | past | favorite | 56 comments





Procedurally generated things are not always as expected:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fG_ErhAeROU


More broadly speaking, liminal spaces

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N63pQGhvK4M


About as scary as the Ikea store - http://www.scpwiki.com/scp-3008


There's a fun little game that procedurally generates an infinite IKEA as the world for an indie survival game. I can't find it anymore but it was a funny concept.


There is one such gamemode for minetest, but it's a bit dull: https://content.minetest.net/packages/benrob0329/ikea/


I think you mean the game "SCP-3008" [1]. If that's the correct one, there's a stream [2] in the LoadingReadyRun youtube channel of people playing it. Not much happens in the video, but maybe the game has evolved in the last three years?

[1] http://thaumielgames.com/index.php/scp-3008/

[2] https://youtu.be/2u4Xe7NaNO8?t=2269


Yep that's the one. Hilarious concept.


There is at least one video game explicitly based on SCP-3008. I'm guessing it's the same one.


I feel good knowing that some people have managed to escape.


Very cool - reminds me a bit of Borges' "Library of Babel". I love the oceanic sense of vastness it gave me while reading it.


If you liked the "Library of Babel", let me highly recommend another story by Borges, "The Immortal". It is perhaps an even stronger match for Ballard's story here and has an especially good depiction of the sort of results that you get from procedural generation:

> /This palace is the work of the gods,/ was my first thought. I explored the uninhabited spaces, and I corrected myself: /The gods that built this place have died./ Then I reflected on its peculiarities, and told myself: /The gods that built this place were mad./ I said this, I know, in a tone of incomprehensible reproof that verged upon remorse--with more intellectual horror than sensory fear. The impression of great antiquity was joined by others: the impression of endlessness, the sensation of oppressiveness and horror, the sensation of complex irrationality.

(There's more to it, but I don't want to spoil it. Suffice to say that this one has something of the antithesis of the nice, neat hexagons in "Library".)


I will check that out, thank you. I should read more Borges. His ability to write very short pieces of text that are interesting and thought-provoking is unmatched.


Reminds me, perhaps ironically, of C.S. Lewis' description of Hell in The Great Divorce.

Canadian public domain link: https://www.fadedpage.com/showbook.php?pid=20140726


Was thinking about the same novel.


My interpretation of this is: they entered a thing that is generating and expanding the further they travel, like world chunks in Minecraft. They're making it bigger by exploring it.


To me it just reads like they landed on an uninhabited Earth, in a time when everyone's already forgotten that people used to live on a planet.


Sounds like maybe you stopped reading halfway through?


Not really. The space travelers become too invested in their beliefs.


From the outside they measured a high gravity even though they estimated 500 meters diameter and there's reason to believe there have been past explorers, so it only makes sense to me if it's actually bigger on the inside. The actual mass and inner depths could be expanding as you posit, though.


It might exist in hyperbolic space; the station folds in on itself. Although it appears to be only a few dozen meters large from the outside, once you're in it's space, it appears much larger (500 meters) and the inside, which is endlessly looping in on itself) contains much more mass than the space should allow, squeezing what seems to be endless amounts of space into finite space.


Somewhat reminescent of House of Leaves. See also the term “Liminal spaces”:

https://imgur.com/gallery/xwOFK


House of Leaves is a great book. ANd in places really creepy and claustraphobic.

I read it on the bus when I used to have to commute for 4 hours a day. Must have looked weird reading this giant book, and at some points reading it upside down, or on its side, or flicking through pages pretty fast (some pages only have 1 or 2 words on them).


I had an opportunity in 2019 to get lost in the Franklin Institute after hours with a couple of friends. Most of the lights were off, not a soul to be found, and some of the normal passageways were locked. The only signs of life was near the event nestled in a small corner at the back of the building, which we had arrived late to and decided not to disturb, choosing to explore instead. Cool experience.

Another take on this idea can be found in the extremely good anime "The Tatami Galaxy".



I remember reading somewhere that this short story inspired "The Parking Garage" episode of Seinfeld.


Am I silly for thinking this was a satirical essay on software estimation?


So I don't quite get it. Is the station a metaphor for them having died and are in some kind of purgatory?


Being Ballard, it’s an allegorical tale, yes, but not for anything so bland as mortality.

The last line, about worshipping the station, is the reveal. Ballard saw within man a tendency to underestimate the depth of the problems he tackled, and a tendency to end up absolutely enmired within false premises, within artifice - these themes are endemic to many of his dystopias.

My best guess is that this is a parable on exactly those themes.


I think Ballard's thing is not about people's tendency to underestimate the weirdness of the universe, but about the universe being far weirder than we think.

Which is very close to being a distinction without a difference, i know. But i think it's rare that Ballard frames this as a flaw in people; rather, it's a terrifying fact about the universe.


I guess it's about the bias towards one's own world view. (And eventually the worship of beliefs, which are mere constructs of our limited knowledge.)

The space travelers travel from transit station to transit station.

What do they assume when they stumble upon an uninhabited Earth? It's a transit station.

It's not only the bias of the space traveler, but also that of the reader who assumes that the space traveler is familiar with the concept of people living on planets, and therefore since the traveler did not conclude that this was an uninhabited planet, the reader already assumes it cannot be Earth.


Was it written by JJ Abrams?


...


I thought the whole point of sci-fi was to comment on society, politics, etc.


I personally like sci-fi for the sci-fi, as long as the story and characters are interesting and well written. It can include commentary on society and politics as a lot of good stories do, but it's not the main reason for reading or watching science fiction for me. It is supposed to be set in a fictional world, after all. One of imagination and exploring possibilities.

And if it's just used as a medium for commenting on contemporary issues, I'm not interested. There's other mediums for that like the news or documentaries.


> It is supposed

I think that begins an overly-subjective line of thinking that just doesn't fit everyone. It certainly doesn't fit me.


Teleologically speaking, that's one of its uses... But I think the whole point of sci-fi is more about story-telling through "what-ifs" of varying feasibility driven by vision and imagination. It's easy for that to become ideological commentary, even propaganda because our visions are affected by our worldview. But personally, I still wouldn't say that commentary defines any genre of writing besides commentary.


Might want to actually Google the author.


This is honestly the most hilarious possible misread of J.G. Ballard, perhaps one of the most overtly politically ideological sci-fi authors who ever wrote. Read High-Rise (or watch the surprisingly good movie!). Read Concentration City.


...


So... Written never ago


You're not familiar with JG Ballard are you?


I’m reminded of the Mexican film ‘El incidente’, probably available on Netflix in your region.


Seconding ‘El incidente’, definitely worth a watch.

Also Blame on Netflix although different sort of theme to this is worth a watch if you want your megastructures itch scratched.


I thought after the second report that this was moving in a very Jean-Paul Sartre direction with the idea of the inhabitants being trapped not just within the station, but in each other's company, infinitely (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Exit).

Was pleasantly surprised by the direction it ended up taking.


Perhaps the architects of this station once read the instructions on a packet of toothpicks.



It’s got a good Rendezvous with Rama vibe to it. Y’all know of any other sci-fi stories in this vein?


This doesn't make much sense. If they're exploring on foot, then on what basis could they estimate any sizes beyond 500 miles or so?


Did you not see that they have instruments?


If their instruments can tell them that the station is 15,000 light years across, then why do they need to explore at all?


The point is the evolving picture revealed by instruments and data collection


Soooo...Heathrow during the pandemic?


Reminds me of the Blame! manga.


"to small"? typo?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: