Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

That's a very dangerous position. If you want to go there you'll find a long list of claims of almost anything.

Take Crimea for example: the Russian Empire only conquered it in the late 18th century (relatively recently too). Should the Turks claim it next (as the Crimean state was the Ottoman Empire's vassal before) or maybe Mongols, Greeks, or descendants of Goths, Huns?

There's a reason for avoiding forceful border carving in the modern world for "historic justice". It is a phony cause and leads to a chain of generational violence. Too bad the modern world never acts to efficiently prevent it.

And by the way, Stalin was already dead by 1954 — difficult to "give" anything in that state. Not even mentioning that "giving" in USSR is just an administrative re-arrangement of a territory within an empire. By that logic, all the states ever being part of any empire have a "historic claim" on the other parts.




Are you saying there are a lot of Turkish people in Crimea?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: