Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

"Arabs aren't forced to do military service but they're welcome to do so"

Exactly the same situation in Apartheid South Africa. There were whole battalions of volunteer black soldiers. Hell, after 1981 there were even black commissioned officers.

But under no circumstances where they arming and training the 'enemy' wholesale - as you said before your edit 'to protect THEIR people'. (Telling choice of words there).

You keep making my case for me.




South africa also had water pipes, so your country is an apartheid country. See? This is silly.

Israel is in a tough situation where there are civilians with relative who swear they want to kill al jews. Israel tries to be fair in this scenario.

A matter of fact is, non jews can vote, join the police the army and the country has laws that gives non jews the same rights as jews. There are scholarship for non jews, and even programs to make sure they are getting to be doctors lawyers etc.

Heck, there are non jewish judges (in the supreme court!), parliament members, and government ministers.

The situation is far from normal or sane, But this is very different than what the situation in SA was.

Now, all of this might change, as there are very dark forces that through the political situation in israel are trying to change israel from being a liberal democracy (at least striving to be) to become a theocracy/ethnocracy.

If they succeed, you might be right in calling israel an apartheid state.


i'm genuinely curious. What is the precise nature of these "Dark Forces" and who are the powers driving them?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: