Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Let me preface this by saying I agree bitcoin is like a decentralised Ponzi scheme...but you are wrong in your assumption that maximum price = number dollars in * number of bitcoins.

The trick of bitcoin is that creates the illusion of value in its price in dollar (or other fiat) terms. There is no true underlying value. Note: bitcoin depends on the dollar because there is no independent bitcoin economy. So the price is simply what fools are willing to pay for it recently, what the last bid was. How much money has gone into the bitcoin black hole over time has almost no bearing on its price at any given instance besides hysteresis (i.e. the current instant price is near the last price).

Price is thus simply the dollar amount that people are willing to pay in the present moment for a bitcoin; there is no reason it could not go to $1,000,000 a coin if people are dumb enough to pay that amount.

This is why bitcoin is like a black hole. It is not an equity, since there is no underlying, fungible asset, i.e. ASIC miners can't be used for general purpose computation, bitcoin is not a share of ownership in anything, etc. The market cap of bitcoin is zero at all times regardless the price. The price provides an illusion of market cap or value but is not actually value in of itself. It exerts a pull on real money that can be used to fund productive or legal investment, like a black hole, but pouring money into Bitcoin does not give it value. Money can be destroyed, just like matter into a black hole and this is something cryptoholders will find out when (1) there is no greater fool left or (2) bitcoin soaks up so much real money that it has real economic effects, e.g. deflation, which results in a regulatory social clampdown or (3) there is a regulatory clamp down before that point due to recognition of bitcoins only real use case, illegal activities.



Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: