Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> One morning I woke up and found that Telegram implemented a new feature called “People Nearby”. If you choose to share your location publicly on Telegram, you’ll appear in a list for users who are physically close to you.

As always, it feels like this "discovery", at least for the headline (which, let's be honest, it's what most people read anyway) is based on glancing over the fact that this feature is opt-in, and that 99,999% of Telegram users do not use it. There's nothing in the headline indicating whether this is a critical data leak or simply expected behavior.

Sure, it definitely falls under unexpected usage of the data, but at the end of the day, the data was shared willfully through user action.




Second paragraph :

> If you’ve never heard of this feature and you suddenly feel the urge to delete your Telegram account forever, let me stress something very important: “People Nearby” is opt-in. By default, no one can see how far away you are on Telegram. You’ll only ever end up in other people’s lists by pressing the “Make Myself Visible” button. If you choose to try it out, remember to disable it once you’re done.


As I said, my issue is mostly with the headline.


Fair - although I'm not big on shifting the blame from people only relying on headlines to form an opinion. That's on them, so-called "clickbait" or not.


If you have "Last Seen & Online" set to "My Contacts", then those people will see you in People nearby even if "Make Myself Visible" is turned off


Do you have a source for this claim? I don’t find this exception documented.


I don't know why i am being downvoted. I tested then and i also have test now. I thought this was the expected behavior. It shows me(who is in their contact list and on completely different network) as online 100m away


> the data was shared willfully through user action.

So it's opt-in, even if you don't tell people what it does when you click that button?

The headline is totally accurate - "Modifying Telegram's “People Nearby” feature to pinpoint people's homes"

> 99,999% of Telegram users do not use it.

Given I can see many people around me this is not true, unless the population is around me is orders of magnitude bigger than it is.


Lol if this is intended behaviour, no one should use Telegram ever again.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: