Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I share your pain, as someone who messes around with game engine dev as a hobby and has also read through that book. He sure made geometric algebra sound like it _should_ be useful, but man is it clear as mud to me.

Of course in general I'm not surprised; for instance I'm not surprised that this paper doesn't have many practical examples. It's higher level math, of course, and for people in that space, showing a small example where you use the geometric product to solve an abstract linear algebra problem is about as close to 'practical' as you are going to get.

But I found it much more aggravating in that book. It's specifically a practical book after all, meant to help lay foundations for renderer and physics engine dev -- but as you said, that section is completely devoid of any real examples of how you could integrate it to make Problem A or B easier, or how it simplifies your transform code, or literally anything. The complete lack of code examples or any such real-world applications make the chapter feel a bit out of place, maybe even tacked on or gratuitous. (Which is a shame because he kind of builds up to that chapter, dropping hints here and there about how it will fundamentally shift our understanding.)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: