Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Most of those issues

Some of these issues

> monomorphization

C++ language is equally bad, but there're well-known workarounds. If you don't abuse Alexandrescu-style, using compilation units, have sane architecture without God objects, it's often not too bad.

> macros

Not just any macros, macros who require multiple passes. C macros are single-pass and pretty efficient.

> build scripts

How that applies to C++?

> how many VMs don't have such escape hatches?

Java doesn't. In C# the hatch exists but can be reliably shut.

> its standard library is probably implemented in unsafe code

No, they don't.

http://www.docjar.com/html/api/java/util/ArrayList.java.html

https://source.dot.net/#System.Private.CoreLib/List.cs




> Java doesn't.

JNI, com.sun.misc.Unsafe, etc

> In C# the hatch exists but can be reliably shut.

P/Invoke?


Technically the unsafe escape hatches exist in those languages, but I think the point is that they are needed less. In Rust you need unsafe to implement some types of graphs, for example, which in GC languages are easy to do without any unsafety.

It's a tradeoff, of course: GC languages let you avoid unsafe code at the cost of doing GCs, which in some applications is an issue. Rust's stroke of genius is that it can avoid GCs while giving you almost all the safety of a GC language.

Overall I think it's safe (no pun intended) to say that Rust is significantly safer than C or C++, but slightly less safe than Java or C#. But of course both of those comparisons have lots of caveats and exceptions. And there are other factors than safety as well.


> JNI

It's so complicated practically no one uses it.

> P/Invoke?

Can be disabled at VM level. Environments like asp.net classic default to partial trust, this ensures vast majority of third-party libraries aren't using p/invoke nor unsafe.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: