Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Great idea. I just left a review. Was asked to register after reviewing. I registered and was brought back to the product page with no review on the page.

I expected the review to be posted. If it's in a moderation queue I'd expect to see a message indicating that's the case. And if the review didn't get saved I probably wouldn't leave another one.




Did you add a review or just a comment? Signup is indeed required for write-operations, but it should bring you back to the product page with the pre-filled comment. Will look into that later, thanks for reporting :)


I don't know the difference between a review and a comment. I reviewed a product in the box under "Discussion" here:

https://www.buyforlifeproducts.com/products/37

BTW for SEO juice you might want to change URLs to include the product slug. E.g. something like:

https://www.buyforlifeproducts.com/products/37-icebreaker-ba...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: