Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> The plans are to build nuclear plants that do exactly no environmental or social damage. Solar/wind/etc can't possibly compete to that standard.

I'm not sure if you're serious with post. "No" environmental damage, when we have to mine uranium, iron ore, and massive amounts of concrete? Yet somehow they "waste" of old solar panels is hazardous to the biosphere and impossible to separate? Nuclear waste is far more hazardous and we don't seem to have much problem isolating that in France.

And then you say that solar is getting a free pass, when you invent issues for solar that are far more difficult for nuclear to handle?

How is this rational in any way?




> when we have to mine uranium, iron ore, and massive amounts of concrete?

If you include the mining that tips the scale even further in the favour of nuclear. A renewables-first strategy use substantially more iron ore and concrete and many more rare-earth metals (which are typically mined in China last time I checked, because they are environmentally damaging to produce). Less uranium with renewables, for obvious reasons, but you can power a country with a very small uranium mine. And again, uranium mines are typically held to higher standards than other mines because they are so small and relatively easy to manage.

> ... Nuclear waste is far more hazardous and we don't seem to have much problem isolating that in France. ...

You seem to be inching towards enlightenment. Keep following that thought.

> you invent issues for solar that are far more difficult for nuclear to handle?

https://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/2017/6/21/are-we-...

I care about the environment when it is convenient. Nuclear remains hands-down the most environmentally friendly option. The only defence renewables have against it is economics (which is a compelling case, I must admit).


The question is energy density and economics. Can solar/wind with the same environmental impact per kWh become cheaper than nuclear? Maybe it's already cheaper. Who knows. So far no one has really pointed at data in this thread.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: