Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm not sold on the idea, merely answering the parent comment that paying the tax would require selling shares. That's not necessarily true.

There's a lot to be said for property taxes. Taxes on income and wealth are disincentives for things you wnt more of. Property tax is one of the least destructive of taxes.

I'm also of a mind that carbon and pollution taxes would be good as well, since the disincentive would be a plus in that case.



> There's a lot to be said for property taxes. Taxes on income and wealth are disincentives for things you wnt more of. Property tax is one of the least destructive of taxes.

Yeah but a wealth tax is not the same as a property tax, because unlike land, wealth is not zero-sum, it's created. In fact, the most economically efficient property tax is the Georgist Land Value Tax which typically deducts the appraised value of improvements before applying the tax, because we don't want to tax productive improvement of land.

Taxing wealth OTOH has the effect of taxing the productive creation of wealth. It's like an inverse Land Value Tax, where you allow one to deduct the value of the underlying land, but simply levy a tax on the appraised value of improvements, just because one might be improving the land "too much".

Also, property taxes are unconstitutional at the Federal level. This is why there is no such thing as a Federal property tax, today. If we wanted a Federal wealth tax, we would have to amend the Constitution.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: