Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> how is that an argument against "We got cheap Chinese plastic trinkets?"

It's not, you just read it that way.

> How is this even connected to the flow of the conversation?

One thing (outsourcing our manufacturing -> getting cheap Chinese shit in return) has clearly led to the other (the profits not trickling down through the economy -> our political parties becoming influence peddlers).

For some bizarre reason you seem really offended by what I wrote. I think that your comment says more about you than what you think it says about me. Have a good one.




>> how is that an argument against "We got cheap Chinese plastic trinkets?"

>It's not, you just read it that way.

Your comment literally started by saying "No." In English, that means you disagree with what I wrote. It's followed by a comma, where in a standard English construction you would present your counterargument.

> For some bizarre reason you seem really offended by what I wrote.

I wasn't offended at all. I was a little overwhelmed by the apparent stupidity of the non sequitur response (and I use 'apparent' very deliberately -- it's possible you miswrote what you meant, or I misread it). I think this summarizes my reaction best:

http://quotegeek.com/quotes-from-movies/billy-madison/1122/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPXEdJ_Gtx0


[flagged]


Please don't respond to someone else breaking the site guidelines by breaking them yourself. That only makes the thread even worse.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


You're right. Sorry, dang.


You literally quoted their assertion and then responded "No".


Yeah, I did. You'll have to forgive me for having been loose with the language I used to write a random comment on the internet. I'm sure I could've worded it differently and in a way that made more sense to the specific context.

You'll also have to forgive me for not responding to that specific critique until you came along, I guess. I'd have been happy to reply to that previously if I hadn't been very condescendingly talked down to about the literal definition of the word no and then told that I ran a household like an asshole, etc...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: