Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

"Whatever" turns out to be a reasonably limited set of exceptions to tectonic boundary models.

Plate tectonics describes and explains the overwhelming majority of known current volcanos and volcanic regions. Mantle plumes, which themselves drive tectonic activity, much the rest.

The overall structure of the Earth, with a thin crust, plastic mantle, and hot core with temperatures resulting from both latent heat of gravitational formation and ongoing radioactive decay itself explains much and is entirely consistent with plate tectonics.

The principle further exceptions might be simply thin crust, or penetrations by impactors --- the universe is complex, volcanos result from escape or exposure of interior magma to the surface by some mechanism. Gods hurling thunderbolts or smithing armour for other gods, for example, has scant evidence.

I'm unaware of any specific terrestrial volcanoes not explained by tectonic or plume mechanisms. There are minor craters (e.g., Ubehebe crater in Death Valley) resulting from steam rather than magmatic bursts, but still driven by geothermal processes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ubehebe_Crater

Further we've now had evidence of similar mechanisms (or their lack) on other bodies, including the Moon (little tectonic activity, some faulting for other reasons, possibly validating Tethys impact formation hypothesis, possible recent volcanism https://coolinterestingstuff.com/volcanoes-erupted-on-the-mo...), Mars (extinct volcanos, former tectonics), Venus (active volcanism, possible tectonics), Mercury (mixed, some faulting thought due to cooling and contraction), and Io (tidal-force induced volcanism), as well as other moons of Jupiter and Saturn.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: