Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's well known you can't smell while you sleep so why is this a good idea?

(Other than the many many other reasons it's a bad idea)




Given how ammonia smelling salts can be used to revive people that are unconscious, I can see how wasabi vapor could have the same effect

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smelling_salts#Usage


"Smelling salts are used to arouse consciousness because the release of ammonia (NH3) gas that accompanies their use irritates the membranes of the nose and lungs, and thereby triggers an inhalation reflex. This reflex alters the pattern of breathing, resulting in improved respiratory flow rates and possibly alertness."

The article on Wasabi says smell, smelling salts are not actually olfactory.


So like what happens if you inhale wasabi?

The article on Wasabi says smell, smelling salts are not actually olfactory.

The article was a few paragraph press release meant for mainstream news, not a technical description.

Elsewhere you can find more details:

Wasabi has a pungent odor that irritates the nose, and it was this property of the plant that was used for the fire alarm

...

When wasabi has been grated, the allyl isothiocyanate contained in it is broken down by an enzyme and becomes a bitter gas that stimulates the nervous system. Surprisingly, it can wake people up, both hearing-impaired and non-hearing-impaired alike, within a period of 10 seconds to two minutes, according to the experiments

https://web-japan.org/trends/11_sci-tech/sci120315.html


So you'd be lightly macing them.

I think it would be hard to get the dosage correct in a room with fans and airconditioning and windows that may or may not be on.

And fun to test every 6 months.

But it is interesting.


Not (always) beeing able to smell during sleep is precisely why we have smoke detectors.


[citation needed]

And, from the article:

He said the Wasabi smoke detector was tested on 14 people, including four deaf people. Except for one person with a blocked nose, all woke up within two minutes of the smell reaching them.


You can look for the wives tale online, but it is a wives tale based on truth

"Minimal Olfactory Perception During Sleep: Why Odor Alarms Will Not Work for Humans"

https://www.vinparleur.net/IMG/pdf/Why_odor_alarms_will_not_...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: