Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Although I disagree (yes the view that his immigration policy is fundamentally rooted in fear of brown people is common) I'm not trying to make it about Trump, or to argue pro or against him per se.

I'm trying to say that the person I responded to is basically strawmaning. No one says that giving affordable housing is necessarily communist. But instead the particular solutions are.

Conservatives want affordable housing too--they just think that other solutions are better.

It's a common argumentative fallacy. If you don't support my solution, you must be against the problem.

If it's fair game to say that Trump's immigration policy has ulterior motives (basically he doesn't want brown people in the country) I think it's fair (maybe not true, but fair game) to say that people who want to tax wealth are communist or communist leaning.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: