Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

>I think not choosing NVidia, especially for the Mac Pro, was a big mistake and costs them customers.

Apple's reluctance to use Nvidia has been a total head scratcher. I owned a 2011 with Nvidia dedicated GPU, but this was the line with known manufacturing defects. I had the mainboard replaced twice because of this issue, but eventually replaced the laptop when the GPU failed again. It's like Apple is holding a grudge.




It's also due to Nvidia's unwillingness to collaborate. AMD allows Apple to maintain their own fork of AMD's drivers for macOS. From what I've heard, AMD also keeps a handful of engineers on premises at Apple campus to assist with work on this fork.

Presumably, Apple wants the same from Nvidia, but Nvidia is notoriously secretive and protective and wants exclusive control over drivers for its hardware.

It's easy to pin this on Apple, but Nvidia's lack of openness shows in FOSS too — where AMD has open sourced the Linux version of their GPU drivers, making AMD GPUs work great out of the box with Linux and allowing for the drivers to follow along with the latest in desktop Linux developments (Wayland, etc), Nvidia has stubbornly insisted on keeping their drivers closed, making for a frustrating install experience, and has actively impeded the development and adoption of Wayland.


I owned an early 2011 15" MBP with a discrete AMD Radeon GPU which had very well known serious manufacturing defects.

I didn't realize Apple had any 2011 model year Macs that used nVidia GPUs.


I think the 2011 was the last year a discrete Nvidia option was available.


They absolutely are because Nvidia blamed Apple for the defects


It's not impossible it's Apple's fault too


It actually was the fault of everyone who implemented the chips, IIRC Nvidia didn't mandate the crap solder that was the problem.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: