Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It not religion per se that's becoming extinct in these nations, it's just some form of Christianity (usually, a very moderate and modernizing form). Detailed demographical studies show that fundamentalist religion (e.g. born again evangelicals and devout Muslims) is definitely on the rise, and associated with by far the largest fertility rates.



In addition, I think it's misleading to count "no affiliation" as "no religious beliefs."

What about new-age spirituality, alternative spirituality, etc.? Those typically don't show up in these kinds of studies, but they do qualify as religious beliefs.


Religion is an institutional and social thing, not just a set of "spiritual" beliefs.


Depending on the country of Europe, you could not register as a "Buddhist"; in Germany it is not an official religion, for example.


Detailed demographical studies show that fundamentalist religion (e.g. born again evangelicals and devout Muslims) is definitely on the rise, and associated with by far the largest fertility rates.

Approximately three minutes after your reply came another reply

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2354753

that cites sources that may allow analysis of what's going on here.


Right, that post however doesn't seem to make a very good conclusion from the numbers presented. I've replied to it in more detail.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: