Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Those who have no stomach for violence can eke out a living snatching cell phones on the subway, which are much easier to convert to cash than stolen credit cards...

At first I thought this was a fake semantic distinction, but now I see: Snatching is not the same as pickpocketing, because the mark helpfully takes out the most valuable item they own and holds it in prime stealing position for you, instead of concealing it in a pocket.

So this seems like the obvious reason why pickpocketing is dying: We've made it too easy. The most easily-fenced, most valuable object I carry is also one which I am very likely to take out and juggle as I wander through crowded places.

Here's where a better article would have coupled the stats on pickpockets with actual stats on public theft and other petty crimes, including things like ATM skimming. (Of course, I believe that all of these things are declining in absolute terms.)




My mother taught me never to take out valuables, especially money, in crowded public places. Isn't this a common teaching, such as "never cross the road without checking for cars"?


In most parts of the US such lessons are rare. I grew up in the Middle East where I learned similar lessons. To many here's unthinkable that one can't just leave their bag lying next to them, or some such.

Heck, outside of the cities many people here don't even lock their doors.


I disagree. I grew up in the US and I keep everything locked, keep my possessions close, watch what is going on around me in crowds, etc.

I'm sure I'm not pickpocket proof but I don't have to be. I just have to not be the easiest one in the area.


Same lessons from India, so I think it's a developing world thing. Or maybe even a high-income-disparity-culture thing?


I think it's a high density thing. Same lessons in Western Europe.


Yes, probably. These things are also common in some parts of Europe. For example, I remember being told to beware of pickpockets and bag snatchers in Spain in the 90s.


Yup, I'm from Turkey. Maybe it is a Middle East thing.


Sure, but the point of smartphones is that you can use them any time, anywhere.


Warnings about crossing the road tend to be more lax in places where there aren't many cars.


A friend of mine had his brand new iPhone 4 snatched on the subway here a few weeks back. It's a real eye opener. You just hold it out there. If you aren't ready for someone to take it, it's trivial to grab it out of your hands and jump out of the doors while they close.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: