Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Yeah, I agree that this place feels too formal at times, and I hate feeling like I have to be a master of rhetoric just to comment here.

In fact just yesterday I got sucked into another thread that went the same way. I've come to the conclusion that that some people take counter points and play Devil's Advocate just because the enjoy argument and debate. Personally it's not my thing. I'd rather dash off a quick comment and get back to work.

This thread has gone crazy, hasn't it?




Sometimes it's because you are encountering someone with a cognitive style that is oriented towards precision of expression. This is an admirable trait that can expose hidden assumptions and lead to valuable insights.

Unfortunately, attacking the form rather than the content of a position can also be an effective tactic for undermining an opposing view without having to risk justifying oneself. It consumes energy without contributing anything constructive. If there's a genuine ambiguity and a desire to work together to learn something, there are usually ways to clarify your opponent's position that help both people reach understanding.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: