Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I think the skepticism is the "quick fix" "trendy" packages that get peddled to businesses or show up in pop culture--like Power Poses or The Secret. Nonviolent Communication isn't the greatest name, either.



Everything ends up being packaged as some get-<blank>-quick scheme in the US, including how to peddle get-<blank>-quick schemes. Don't blame the idea for the hucksters.


Heuristics in action. I can‘t possibly number all the different BS methodologies and frameworks that were supposed to do something, every time.

Applicable and actually highly successful ones like NVC are few and far between.

Can‘t blame anyone who smells a fad on hearing it the first time, but I‘m also using NVC by now whenever I need to untangle difficult conversations.


Violent communication is hitting someone to make a point. The name of this is insulting.


Violence isn't always physical.


Indeed. I'm also fairly sure that calling it non-violent communication was no quick decision and was at least partly chosen to make us consider whether our usual methods are in fact violent and thus harmful.


I agree with this but I still think it is a bad name. Maybe something like non-aggressive communication would fare better?


Violence is always physical, by definition. Sometimes the word is also used for poetic effect though.


May I refer you to the second definition of violence, per Merriam Webster?

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/violence

Violence, by definition, is not always physical.


The same dictionary that defines literally as both literal and not literal. Dictionaries are descriptive not prescriptive, and so they also account for incorrect but common usage.


If enough people use literally in that manner than it is indeed correct. This is how language works, regardless if you like the change or not. Languages are always evolving and dictionaries reflect that.


In the same vein, language is constantly in flux, so defining a thing as "just so" is at best a temporary accuracy.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: