Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

but maybe Schwab provides a relatively non-predatory version of it

They will pull from your brokerage account, if you have insufficient funds they'll take out a margin loan and I think the only fees there are interest.

ING did something similar where they'd only charge you interest for overdraft stuff.




>if you have insufficient funds they'll take out a margin loan

That's not my experience with them. I've had them as a checking/brokerage account for 10+ years. I tend not to keep much money in checking so I run into timing issues once a year or so - where a check I wrote will present before the funds to cover it arrive in my account. I've definitely had them pull from the brokerage cash, but not from savings. They have never opened a margin loan to cover it.


Also not my experience. Accidentally had a timing issue once, and was overdrawn for a week before an ACH more than covered the difference.

On day four they called me to make sure I was aware. I explained that I had already started a transfer several days earlier, and they said "no problem" and thanked me for being a customer.

No overdraft fees, no pulling from my brokerage account, no margin loan. Never heard anything about it ever again.


It's happened to me a couple times as I don't keep cash in my brokerage account. To cover the checking account, they'll pull from the brokerage account, and if there's insufficient cash in the brokerage account, they take a margin loan. vOv




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: