Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Germany is obviously somewhat keen on letting single entities get control of everything, as the EU is in many ways an extension primarily of Germany, and the closest entity I'm aware of that could be said to be doing just that.

I'd also like to mention that certain entities operating outside of the state are precisely the sort of thing that can prevent the sort of tyranny that Germany enacted during the 20th century. Sometimes, and often, the entity capable of "regulating" is the tyranny. Imagine if Germany had had the capability to prevent payments to Jews, or track which households were spending more on food than they should and were likely harboring enemies of the state. I'm not saying Facebook needs to be the entity that does it, but monetary systems operating outside of the state could be argued to be one of the strongest weapons against tyranny.

I actually think this highlights one of the fundamental differences between Western liberalism and German schools of thought. Germany tends to fall back on the central authority, whereas liberalism thinks that the central authority is the single most corruptible attack vector.




> Germany is obviously somewhat keen on letting single entities get control of everything, as the EU is in many ways an extension primarily of Germany, and the closest entity I'm aware of that could be said to be doing just that.

I'm not sure a union with a democratically elected parliament is comparable to a social media corporation which answers to its shareholders?


Why can other people not make that comparison? You seem to be doing just that -

A has a democratically elected parliament

B answers to its shareholders


I'm pointing out it's just not relevant to the conversation. They're too different to meaningfully (in good faith) bring up as a discussion point.

The original comparison read very much as whataboutism to me.


> monetary systems operating outside of the state could be argued to be one of the strongest weapons against tyranny

This is in direct contradiction to your previous paragraph, unless such a system is inherently decentralized, and not controlled by a single entity (such as FB).


Facebook would already make the situation into 2 competing entities, as the state will always be the other.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: