Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Price control is not a theory. There are several books, papers (Hayek, Mises, Friedman), topics that address this topic. If it is so good, why isn't implemented? It's the same argument than communism: if it is so good, why we don't implement it? Because it doesn't work. It never worked.

Price control generates scarcity. Because bureaus can't have all the information about the market, it's impossible. The moment a bureau determinate a price you're generating an impact on the different areas without having the possibility to address it. The gov. is not the market, the gov can't be an omnipotent entity that knows everything, that's why they screw everything.



It's more or less implemented for medical care in most other first-world countries and it seems to work better than ours* in all of them.

I lived in Canada for three years, and growing up in a fairly conservative area in the US, I was prepared for the worst - six-month wait times for life-saving procedures, etc. What I saw was more like Star Trek - people who needed medical care went to a clinic or hospital and got it, and they didn't have to worry about being bankrupted in the process.

After I moved back to the US, I got to see what it was like for most people - delaying or never getting critical procedures done, people with teeth rotting in their heads because they can't afford to go to the dentist, almost everyone 1 unexpected medical bill away from permanent financial ruin. Our system is objectively bad, and we deserve to feel bad for sticking with it.

You can cite all the market theory you want, but the US is a perfect empirical example of why those theories are wrong.

* Except for the tiny minority of the ultra-wealthy who can afford to pay any price for health care.


> Hayek, Mises, Friedman

What a diversity of thinkers!


Do you want more? I've read others. You want me to bow before Marx or Keynes? LOL




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: