Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Your website and documentation is all a bit opaque.

The title reads like a new encryption library for in the browser but in reality is an (advert for) encryption service, the SDK is open source because it requires your backend with its "Trustchain", the wording on the website is vague about how the Trustchain Private Key is "obtained".

Regarding the service, my main issue is that with an open source SDK you're aiming at a certain type of people, developers, like many of us, but I see no mention of the algos used which immediately causes me to lose interest (between that and the sales/marketing heavy website). If you're really targeting developers I would suggest losing the marketing babble and get down to brass tacks.

And finally, if the private key really is generated on your service, we can just pack up and go home.

What it sounds like you have is a PKI infrastructure with open source SDK and "end-to-end" encryption of things, as much as end-to-end applies for keys/trust roots generated anywhere but locally.

If any/all of this is wrong, please clarify.



> how the Trustchain Private Key is "obtained".

The Trustchain private key is generated when you create a Trustchain. It is generated on your machine. You can try it and create a Trustchain yourself here: https://dashboard.tanker.io/

> And finally, if the private key really is generated on your service, we can just pack up and go home.

It is not :)

> What it sounds like you have is a PKI infrastructure with open source SDK and "end-to-end" encryption of things, as much as end-to-end applies for keys/trust roots generated anywhere but locally.

That's pretty much it. The trust root is that Trustchain key, and Tanker never sees its private part.

> Regarding the service, my main issue is that with an open source SDK you're aiming at a certain type of people, developers, like many of us, but I see no mention of the algos used which immediately causes me to lose interest (between that and the sales/marketing heavy website). If you're really targeting developers I would suggest losing the marketing babble and get down to brass tacks.

I take note of this. The parts targeted at developers available at the moment are the documentation, the code examples, and the SDK sources. We will write and publish something that explains how it works under the hood.


Thanks for clarifying all that.

It'll really benefit from some clarity on those points in the documentation.


>And finally, if the private key really is generated on your service, we can just pack up and go home.

Yeah, thankfully that key is generated client-side (in the browser) when you register. Seems pretty end-to-end to me.

(And sure, you could always worry that the server will serve you malicious JS while you're registering to steal your client-side-generated key, but that would be pretty suicidal for any company, not a very realistic threat!)


Yeah it's sounds reasonable within those constraints given the clarification above.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: