In fact, HN was originally called "Startup News", so it was even more tied to the idea of making money. And yeah, the idea was always to be a place for YC discussion:
"our hope is that by creating a community at news.ycombinator, we'll be able to get to know would-be founders before they apply to us."
"our hope is that by creating a community at news.ycombinator, we'll be able to get to know would-be founders before they apply to us."
https://news.ycombinator.com/announcingnews.html