Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

"Create more money"? If you mean printing more money, than we just get inflation, otherwise giving money doesn't create any new value by itself, it's just money changing hands.



Yes, UBI would likely contribute to some inflation -- a little bit of inflation is good, necessary, and unavoidable. It would also act as a massive stimulus to the economy, while also empowering economically-disenfranchised people to enter into the market, from which they are barred from participating in without money.

One way to fund a UBI would be through a value-added tax, which would be collected at every stage of production where money is exchanged.


Inflation is an unvoted and unregulated tax; being a flat tax it is regressive and it vastly disproportionately (negatively) affects the poor.

It is not good, nor a benefit.


Inflation is not a tax: there is no government entity that collects inflation payments.

Not having any money is worse for the poor than having a basic income, even if there is inflation. The market has no direct incentive to serve those without money. The alleviation of widespread human suffering due to poverty and the massive increase in the general utility of the market to humans clearly makes UBI the moral choice.

Inflation does benefit debtors: with money being cheaper, loans are easier to pay off.


> Inflation is not a tax: there is no government entity that collects inflation payments

Quite the opposite; when new money enters circulation it is spent (by those doing the printing) at the pre-inflation value of the notes.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: